For walks on the leash, a harness is the better choice for most dogs. The collar stays for the ID tag and for dogs that walk calmly on a loose leash.
| Situation | Collar | Harness |
|---|---|---|
| Dog pulls on the leash | the pull hits the neck | spreads the pull across chest and back |
| Small or short-nosed dog | can become uncomfortable on the neck | rests on a larger area |
| ID tag and everyday life at home | a good fit | not necessary |
| Visibility in the evening | light-up collar possible | reflectors on the back |
| Long line | not suitable | belongs on the harness |
Why many people choose a harness
According to the description, an H-harness like the Trixie Premium H-Rig distributes pressure better than a collar. It is made of sturdy webbing, is infinitely adjustable and has snap buttons for quick fitting. A harness does not replace training, but it makes the pull more comfortable for your dog. How to deal with pulling is explained in Dog pulls on the leash: What helps.
What the collar is still for
The ID tag belongs on a well-fitting collar. Two fingers should fit underneath. The Morso collar made of recycled material is infinitely adjustable and, according to the description, does not pull on the fur. For dog and leash together, there is the ne&no collar and leash set made of vegan leather, padded on the inside and wipe-clean.
Being seen in the dark
The Trixie light-up collar has a light that flashes or stays on continuously, is charged via USB and is splash-proof. You can find more ideas for being clearly visible in the evening in Walks in the dark: being seen without looking silly.
Material and care
Nylon webbing is sturdy and dries quickly. Padded inner sides are more comfortable if the coat is thin. You wipe leather-like materials clean instead of washing them. Check the care label: Some harnesses can go in the washing machine, others are hand-washed.
Puppies and young dogs
Many people start with a harness because the puppy is only just learning to walk on a leash and does not yet know how to behave. Choose an adjustable model, because your puppy grows quickly, and check the fit regularly.
The fit check
Two fingers should fit under every strap, nothing should chafe in the armpits and the harness should not slip when your dog turns. How to measure your dog's chest girth and what else matters is explained in the Dog Harness Guide. You can find all models in the Harnesses & Leashes collection.